Activities & games
Counseling Games for Students Who Are Reluctant to Talk
Try six low-pressure conversation cards, a ready-to-say opening, and age adaptations that let students answer, point, ask the counselor, or pass.
When a student does not want to talk, a game can offer a less demanding way to begin. It does not have to lead to a personal disclosure to be worthwhile. Start with predictable rules and neutral prompts, join the activity yourself, and let the student control how much they share. These are original engagement ideas, not a treatment protocol or evidence that one game works for every student.
START HERE
Take turns without a score for sharing
Grades K–12 with adaptations · Start with a few minutes
- Say: ‘You can answer, point, ask me to answer first, or pass. We can choose something else.’
- Begin with a neutral choice: ‘Would you rather read beside a window or draw at a big table?’
- Take a brief, appropriate turn yourself, then let the student choose another card or stop.
- Close with: ‘Would you use these again, change them, or choose something else?’
Start with choice instead of a surprise question
Explain any school-related limits on confidentiality in developmentally appropriate language before inviting personal discussion. Do not present a game as a secret test. Offer an alternative such as drawing, a quiet shared task, or returning to the conversation later when that is appropriate.
We can try a few cards together. You can answer, point, ask me to answer first, or pass. There are no points for sharing something personal. We can stop or choose something else.
Six conversation cards to try now
Choose a place
Would you rather read beside a window or draw at a big table? What makes that spot appealing?
Small win
What is something a person can get better at with practice?
Helpful words
A classmate says, ‘I do not know where to start.’ What could someone say?
Pick a break
Would a quiet minute, a stretch, or a short walk be your first choice for a break?
Change one thing
If a fictional school could add one useful space, what could it be?
Ask the adult
Choose one of these cards for the counselor to answer. You can ask one follow-up question or pass.
How the counselor participates
Take a turn and give a brief, appropriate answer that keeps the focus on the student. For the helpful-words card, you might say, ‘I could ask which part they want help with first.’ Avoid turning your response into a long personal story or adding a counseling question after every card.
Reflect one thing you heard without interpreting more than the student said: ‘You picked the quieter spot.’ Then ask whether to choose another card, switch roles, or stop. A student who points, passes, or asks you a question is still participating in the agreed activity.
Adapt the game to the student’s grade and access needs
Check reading, language, sensory, and communication preferences rather than assuming grade alone tells you what will work. ASCA’s ethical guidance calls for attention to developmental and language factors when considering assessment appropriateness; a conversation game itself should not be represented as an assessment.
| Grade band | Simple adaptation |
|---|---|
| K–2 | Read one prompt aloud and offer two visible choices. Accept pointing, drawing, or watching your turn. |
| 3–5 | Alternate turns. Let the student choose which card you both answer. |
| 6–8 | Use ordinary school situations and let the student change an unrealistic detail. |
| 9–12 | Offer a choice of neutral conversation or a practical school scenario; avoid a childish presentation. |
Reference: ASCA ethical standards: developmental and language considerations
End without making disclosure the score
- Ask: ‘Would you use these cards again, change them, or choose something else?’
- If a useful next step came up, ask permission to return to it.
- Do not infer a diagnosis, risk level, or lack of need from passing or from one answer.
- If a safety concern comes up, pause the game and use your school’s established response procedures.
READY TO USE
A simple play-together plan
Print the guide for the six cards, or copy this short plan for your preparation.
Offer: choose a card / point / ask the counselor / pass
Counselor opening: We can stop or choose something else.
A neutral card to begin: ____________________
An alternative if the game is not a fit: ____________________
Closing question: Use this again, change it, or try something else?